Joe Glenton bobbed up on the local news again today. He joined the army in 2004, and in 2007 went AWOL from the war in Afghanistan. In 2009, his court marital began in Bulford, Wiltshire. Glenton argued that because he believed the conflict was illegal (and said he would produce an expert in international law who could prove that), he was not a deserter but simply an absentee without leave. In March of this year he was jailed for nine months - ironically the same amount of time he went between deployments in Afghanistan.
My first reaction about this case was that Joe Glenton's argument was ludicrous. A soldier cannot join up and then pick and choose which battles he is willing to fight. If we're going to get down to brass tacks here, surely all wars involve illegality of one sort or another, one of the simplest forms being the fact that it is against the law to take the life of another human being. It surely must flicker across the frontal lobe of anyone joining the army that at some point or another they might have to kill another person, or do something else they generally don't agree with for the good of the unit.
I do not agree with the war in Afghanistan. I did not believe the war in Iraq was legal or justified in any sense. But I am not in the army. Unfortunately, if one is a soldier, one must put up and shut up.
In the army, a person is simply a number, a body to be used in the fight against the enemy, who or whatever that may be. The army breaks you down and builds you up, into a fighting machine that obeys orders. That is why to function in civilian life can be difficult and ex-soldiers complain that the army's provision for mental health issues is poor. A soldier is simply a flesh and blood cog in a huge war machine. The army is only interested in a soldier's short-term killing potential, not their long-term mental fitness. Unfortunately, with flesh and blood comes emotions and feelings - and thoughts.
Army guidelines (and unfortunately, that's all they are) recommend eighteen months between tours of duty. Joe Glenton got nine months before he was sent back into the killing zone. This is an attitude towards its soldiers which appears to be prevailing in the army at the moment, certainly in America. Minds deal with stress in various different ways. Glenton has post-traumatic stress disorder. He disappeared from Afghanistan for two and a half years before handing himself in. Now the anti-war lobby are holding him up as a martyr for their cause.
In war, no one ever really wins.
